By Randy Vogt

It’s the most basic principle of any game officiated by the use of a whistle: Play stops when the whistle sounds. Players are told to play the whistle andsoccer players can be cautioned if they play the ball a second or two after they hear the whistle. So it’s particularly frustrating that two refs during televised games in the past year blew thewhistle for a penalty kick, then allowed the goal to stand when the ball went into the goal, not having the PK taken instead.

In the Red Bulls-Portland Timbers game last August, refereeJason Anno blew the whistle for a Red Bulls penalty kick for a handling foul inside the penalty area. The ball then rebounded from Portland defender DavidHorst’s arm to the Red Bulls’ Tim Cahill, who shot and scored. Cahill’s shot was by the top of the penalty area. As the ball was going toward the goal, Annoblew his whistle for the PK, then allowed the goal to stand. He should have taken the ball out of the net and given a penalty kick instead.

That situation repeated itself in theBrazil-Italy Confederations Cup game this past Saturday. Uzbekistanian referee Ravshan Irmatov blew the whistle and pointed to the penalty spot when Mario Balotelliwas dragged to the ground off a corner kick. Then he allowed Giorgio Chiellini’s shot by the penalty spot, that occurred as the whistle was sounding, to stand. Again, the ref should have takenthe ball out of the goal and given the penalty kick.

Teams score on penalty kicks the great majority of the time. The only time that a ref should try and play the advantage for a penaltykick foul is when an attacking player has the ball near the goal with an open goal beckoning.

One of the reasons that referees carry the whistle in their hands, is by raising it to theirmouths, gives them an opportunity to see if an advantage situation is developing. It would have been great if the refs in these two situations could have waited an extra split second to see if anadvantage situation had developed but I cannot fault them for blowing the whistle as fouls were committed and there’s a much higher probability of the penalty being converted than the followingshot.

In games that I have refereed, approximately five times I’ve had to take the ball out of the net as I blew the whistle for a penalty kick before the ball went into the goal.The last time occurred two weeks ago. I can honestly write that I was really hoping that all those penalty kicks would be converted. All were except one years ago. I felt bad about that one time butwhat could I do? I had to forget about it and continue to ref the game.

I’ve also played the advantage several times when, after a defensive foul inside the penalty area, the ballwent to an attacker near the goal who had an open goal to shoot at. All times, the goal was scored.

An NCAA game a few years ago was protested as the losing team had video that the refblew the whistle before the ball entered the goal, then gave the goal. The NCAA ordered the match to be replayed which was the correct decision.

In the situation in MLS last year and inthe Confederations Cup this past weekend, the refs created problems by allowing the goal to stand. How can we tell players to play the whistle if the ref allows play to continue after the whistle?

(Randy Vogt has officiated over 8,000 games during the past three decades, from professional matches in front of thousands to 6-year-olds being cheeredon by very enthusiastic parents. In his book “PreventiveOfficiating,” he shares his wisdom gleaned from thousands of games and hundreds of clinics to help referees not only survive but thrive on the soccer field. You can visit the book’swebsite at www.preventiveofficiating.com/)

Join the Conversation

6 Comments

  1. By disallowing the goal and calling for a penalty kick instead you are giving the advantage to the team making the infractions. The advantage rule exists for a reason. I admit that the ref blew the whistle calling for a penalty kick, but the goal was converted practically simultaneously with the whistle, so, in my opinion, the goal was rightly allowed.

  2. I’m with Oswald on this! As a Ref you should know there is no law governing the whistle and the Ref has every option to alter his call esp. when it comes to playing advantage. I think you are overly swayed by the idiot commentators on this one.

  3. By law like it or not the whistle stops playAnd if the ball has not fully crossed goal line. Justfully , not legally I agree w/ Oswald that The ref got it right in the end, b/c Brasil did not Let up on the split second between whistleAnd second strike. As a ref of soccer and otherSports as hard as it is you want to make quickDecisive calls or “sell the call”. But in certain situations especially scoring opportunities A ref should hold the call to let the play finish Out. Easier said than done in many times. There are occasions that the whistle starts playPlay from dead ball situations. I think commentators all to often hammer refsFor a bad call and band them from big games. Human error is part of the game in any officiatingArena. Now if this is common place then addressIt constructively. Too many times sideline yahoosSpout off and rip refs of all ages. This is the Main reason many young refs quit for the smallBucks ; just not worth it! That is a whole otherTopic.

  4. Difficult situation, but should justice or legality prevail? Do you want human judgment or mechanical consistency? If the ref blows the whistle and the defense stops on the whistle, then the offense scores (and they might not have scored had the whistle not blown), then clearly the ref blew it (sorry), but you have to take the goal away and award the PK. On the other hand, if the whistle does not effect play, judgment would suggest justice would be served to allow the goal to stand. And of course, allowing advantage to be played when an offensive player has the opportunity to score (but then fails to do so), presents a slightly different problem. Do you then award the pk (even though the offense “should” have scored?). Justice would say yes, the laws of the game say otherwise.

  5. Having been “guilty” of this infraction….and regretting it. I must go with the RULE. Referees need to take a breath, count to 3, whatever, to allow time to establish advantage…or not. If we start saying (as some have). Yeah; it’s the rule, but. Then we have no rules!

  6. Only in hindsight can we sat justice was served in this situation where goal would have been scored even w the split second whistle where we have the luxury of review. Of course a ref cannot officiate w what happensIn retrospect. If the whistle blasts then no goal and subsequent PK. Soccer of all sports allowsThe ref to not make harsh speedy calls. Because He/she must bring their whistle to their mouth prior to the blast. Hold your whistle as mentionedFor 2 seconds new refs !

Leave a comment