Liviu Bird, who’s been covering the quest of American youth clubs to receive compensation via FIFARegulations on the Status and Transfer of Players (RSTP) for their players who go on to pro careers, got hold of U.S. Soccer’s written responses to questions submitted by Senator MariaCantwell (D., Washington) on the federation’s lack of adherence to RSTP. The questions were a follow-up to the U.S. Senate consumer protection subcommittee hearing into the FIFAscandals. U.S. Soccer’s responses into why it has prevented training compensation and solidarity payments to reach youth clubs as they do in other nations include a reference to the landmark caseof Fraser v. MLS in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts in 1996, in which U.S. Soccer agreed “it would not enforce transfer fee or similar restrictions that FIFA might impose onthe movement of players who were ‘out of contract.’” As to why U.S. Soccer has not created a U.S. system for compensating U.S. youth clubs, U.S. Soccer’s answer included: “The statedgoal of the RSTP system is to compensate amateur teams for their investment in player development. Historically, in the United States (as distinct from many countries elsewhere throughout the world),the cost of player training and development was typically borne by the families of young players, and in the case of top-level players, by U.S. Soccer itself.”

Humm.!?!?… The Plot Thickens,,,Where is The Money from the Overseas Transfers???…Foreign Teams say They Paid It…MLS and USSF say “No”…
If USSF wants a MESSI, Just Give Payments to the Teams that Produce these type of Players…Instead of Athletic, Win at all Cost Trophy Hunting Teams, We will get REAL Player Development…
Throw in the 115 Regional Training Centers that the Germans Instituted in 1996(BEFORE KLINSMANN)(Read “DAS REBOOT” article) and Individual Skill and Technical Development will be the Result…In 6 years we can have a Messi, Ronaldo, Xavi, Iniesta, Ibra,…Etc..Etc…
” …in the case of A FEW top-level players, by U.S. Soccer itself.” There, fixed it.
It’s time US Soccer kept MLS at arms length from here on out. MLS does not represent the best interests of youth soccer in this country, despite these court rulings that apparently prevent the payments afforded to clubs in the rest of the world.
So MLS deserves the FULL training compnsation it gets from these other clubs for 1-2 years of free training?? What about solidarity payments?? What about transfer fees?? Those werent meant to cover youth costs. This is why USSF jumped every 2 years and are down to U!2 by next year instead of doing what makes sense development wise and started U15 and U13 division before this. What a joke.
No Court Ruling against Players “Under Contract”…USSF says the “Understanding” in Fraser v MLS, is about No Fees for Players “Out of Contract”…Even FIFA Statutes Don’t require FEES on “Out of Contract” players…USSF and MLS Pulled the Wool over the Judges Head…
You are Correct…They are trying to Out Flank the Youth Clubs…
Where the Questions posed by the Senator from Washington, the Only Additional Written Questions Posed by the Committee Members.???…4 seems too small a number.!?!?
Why is USSF trying so hard to not help youth clubs get compensated but trying to ensure MLS does?? MLS clubs make alot of $$$ with these youth club partnerships they get through membership fees anually and unfirom packages that run above $350. Thats alot of money profit they get directly from parents that more than accounts for DA costs and then some. Our federation should be only involved to make sure MLS produces better players. Should have nothing to do with who gets a profit much less denying basic rights. Why are we critisizng FIFA so hard when our own federation is probably worse?
Correcta Mundo.!!! Señor Madness..
dont forget all the lame training by good looking english guys (targeting the moms) who are targeted to local low-mid level travel clubs & rec leagues as a great training options. The clubs charge $75-150 hr for training they pay them $10-15hr put them up 5-10 to a 4Br house. classic cheap outsourcing.
Aaron, that is exactly correct. And people wonder why so many Top World Clubs are targeting the USA market on youth side.