By Paul Gardner Once in a while, a glimpse of undeniable reality disturbs the comfortable certainties of English refereeing attitudes. The least acceptable — and the leastexplicable — of those certainties is the notion that whenever a referee is uncertain about a call, he gives the benefit of his doubt to the defending team. Because […]
referees
When Should a Ref Retire?
By Randy Vogt I canhear the snickers already from fans who would like to answer the headline above by saying, “The ref we had at our last game should have retired a long time ago!” Pope Benedict had it rightregarding retirement. He thought that he was not physically up to the job anymore so he […]
The Latest Wrongheaded Ref-Bashing
By Paul Gardner Here we go again, alas, alas. And, for me, it really is alas, because once again we’ve got a good young American coach losing it and berating the referee. Afew weeks back, it was John Hackworth and Caleb Porter. This time it’s D.C.United’s Ben Olsen erupting after his team’s 1-0 loss to […]
The whistle means stop
By Randy Vogt It’s the most basic principle of any game officiated by the use of a whistle: Play stops when the whistle sounds. Players are told to play the whistle andsoccer players can be cautioned if they play the ball a second or two after they hear the whistle. So it’s particularly frustrating that […]
What They're Saying
“FIFA is like God. They decide the rules.” — Brigitte Frot, executive director of the Quebec soccer federation after it lifted its ban onplayers wearing turbans, saying clarifications from FIFA provided the reassurance it needed. (Montreal Gazette)
Refereeing Young Children: More Teacher than an Enforcer (Part 1)
By Randy Vogt When I started refereeing in 1978, young kids games were 11 vs. 11. I was paid $6 per game, or $4 if I refereed with a partner. Being givenresponsibilities and some authority while running up and down a soccer field was probably the best job that a teenager could have. Nearly all […]
Cahill's 'rough up' comment calls for response from MLS
By Paul Gardner An interesting game — I’m talking about this past weekend’s Red Bulls-L.A. Galaxy game. A 1-0 win for the Bulls, a win they probably didn’tdeserve, but a win they snatched at the very last moment of the game, pouncing on a bad mistake by the Galaxy’s 39-year-old, and very experienced, Italian goalkeeper […]
What They're Saying
“We seem to be the lab rats to get more games for young referees and I don’t like it at all. I think it’s inappropriate to have one team subject to more experiencedreferees.” — Toronto FC president Kevin Payne, bemoaning the inexperienced referees his team seems to get on a regular basis. He said six […]
When Lightning Threatens: Safety Comes Before Soccer
By Randy Vogt I became frustrated, exasperated and annoyed. Earlier that week, I had told the home team coach that I would be a little late as my previousgame was going to finish a few minutes before the kickoff time of his game and that game was four miles away. When I got into my […]
The Death of a Referee: Make it an Hour of Silence
By Mike Woitalla “The yells and insults from the sideline from the parents make kids more violent.” — Utah referee PedroLopez, the brother-in-law of 46-year-old referee RicardoPortillo, who died last week after being punched by a 17-year-old goalkeeper. In addition to working as an editor of Soccer America my whole adult life, I have been […]
