1. Philadelphia (2015 U.S. Open Cup final), 1-1, then 7-6 (2 saves)
2. San Jose (2017 U.S. Open Cup), 1-1, then 5-3 (2 saves)
3. Vancouver (2020 MLS is Back), 0-0, then 3-1 (2 saves)
4. San Jose (2020 MLS playoffs), 3-3, then 3-0 (3 saves)
5. San Jose (2023 MLS playoffs), 0-0, then 4-2 (1 save)
Note: Melia also won shootouts with the Rochester Rhinos (2009) and Charleston Battery (2010) against MLS teams in the U.S, Open Cup.

SUBSCRIBE TO KEEP READING

Start for $0 & enjoy free unlimited access for 30 days.

  • Daily TV listings for U.S. and global soccer.
  • Inside access to USA’s 2026 World Cup prep.
  • Exclusive interviews with players and coaches.
  • Expert analysis of top soccer headlines.
  • Cancel anytime.

Already have an account? Sign in here.

CHECK OUT MORE STORIES

Not ready to subscribe? Sign up here for our free newsletter.

Already have an account? Sign in here.