screen-shot-2015-09-01-at-30318-pm

By Mike Woitalla

If I had a dollar for every time a foreign club offered to teach us how to coach, I’d be able to buy one of the replica jerseys they’re selling.

I certainly don’t think it’s a bad idea for American soccer to consider the methods used in other countries, and to adopt those that might benefit our players. I’ve visited theyouth programs of Barcelona, Bayern Munich and Boca Juniors, Tahuichi in Bolivia, and have attended countless coaching “clinics” run by foreign coaches. And I’ve seen stuff thatmakes good sense to me.

I also find it laughable that foreign clubs that hardly, if ever, produce their own players claim they can teach us how to do it. The first questions we should askourselves when clubs or coaches from abroad come here offering their services are:

1. What is their track record of producing talent?

2. Do they play the kind of soccer we’restriving for?

3. What’s in it for them?

In August, U.S. Club Soccer announced “a technicalpartnership” with Spain’s La Liga. According to the U.S. Club Soccer, La Liga is “investing significant resources in U.S. youth soccer development.”

So what’s in it forthem?

“They’ve been upfront about it,” says U.S. Club Soccer’s Executive Director/CEO Kevin Payne. “They realize they have not done a very goodjob marketing the La Liga brand. They believe that if they ask Americans to consume their product, they should first give something to American soccer. To share their knowledge and help the gamegrow.”

La Liga will provide U.S. Club Soccer clubs with training curriculum. The partnership includes “reciprocal coaching education seminars and elite player trainingopportunities abroad” and “direct involvement” with U.S. Club Soccer’s player identification programs.

“I believe it’s the best league in the world,”Payne says. “Certainly there’s no argument about that from UEFA.”

La Liga tops the UEFAclub competition rankings by a significant margin. Spanish clubs have won five of the last 10 Champions League crowns and six of the last 10 Europa League titles (formerly UEFA Cup).

“And obviously Spain as a nation is very successful,” says Payne. “I also believe La Liga is the most attractive in terms of style. …

“The English PremierLeague had a 15-year head start [in marketing to U.S. fans]. And if you say the Premier League is the best in the world over and over and over again, people start to believe it. But they’rereally only No. 1 in money.

“When EPL clubs come to the United States, it’s always about making money, slapping their names on clubs’ jerseys. I can only think of maybe oneor two exceptions, Manchester City in particular, whose ventures here aren’t just about making money.”

Payne has a strong case for La Liga. While its clubs’ success isobviously also thanks to foreign imports, La Liga’s percentage of foreign players last season of 39% is less than the English Premier League (69%), Italy’s Serie A (55%) and the GermanBundesliga (46%). Moreover, Spain was second only to France in exporting players to top European leagues.

Plus, with European Championship titles in 2008 and 2012 sandwiching a 2010 World Cuptitle, Spain is the most successful national team of the last decade. (Spain also won the 2011 and 2013 U-21 European Championships and three of the last five U-19 European Championships.)

“I believe they have an enlightened approach,” Payne says. “It’s a great marriage for us. But it’s not a silver bullet. I think one of the biggest problems in Americansoccer is believing there’s one elixir and everything is going to be great. This is just another tool in the toolbox for us. And for them, it’s a way to develop fans.”

As faras the Spanish and La Liga style of soccer having a positive influence on young American players – I won’t argue against that.

PLAYERS FIRSTINITIATIVE. The La Liga partnership is part of U.S. Club Soccer’s Players First initiative – “a holisticclub soccer experience for parents and players, which emphasizes the development of each individual to his or her full potential, and helps parents make better choices about where their childrenshould play” — it launched last month, encompassing the five pillars of “Club Development, Coaching Development, Player Development, Parent Engagement & Education, Player Health & Safety.”

Around the Net

Sam Borden of theNew York Times checks in with the family of 15-year-old California product Ben Lederman, who joined Barcelona in 2011 but for the last year has been banned from playing in games forBarcelona’s youth teams because of FIFA’s enforcement of its ban on the transfer of minors across international borders. “It is killing him,” said Ben’s father, DannyLederman. “And as his dad, it’s killing me, too, to see him like this. A year? Kids need to play; he practices, he practices, he practices, but he can’t play? It’s notright. … I understand the rule was made to protect kids from being pulled away from their families. But our family made a choice to move to Spain together. Why should FIFA be able to tell our familywhere it has to live if we want our kid to play soccer?” The Ledermans are considering taking their case to the Court of Arbitration for Sport and challenging the basic notion of the rule thatcreated it. “Strict Enforcement of FIFA RulesSidelines Young Players Abroad”

USSoccer.com features a video of 17-year-old Mallory Pugh, the USA’s mosthighly touted female teen, and her experience of training with the full national team. Pugh, at age 16, started all four games for the USA at the 2014 U-20 Women’s World Cup. The Real Coloradoforward, who graduates from high school in 2016 and has committed to UCLA, is currently leading the USA’s quest to qualify for the 2016 U-20 Women’s World Cup. “Mallory Pugh: A Day in The Show”

Join the Conversation

29 Comments

  1. Don’t forget that the trio of Sporting, Porto, and Benfica point to a strong Portugese capability. If you look at their finances you will see that these clubs actually *survive* by selling players, so they have a lot more skin in the game than most.

  2. Hmmm, so La Liga is partnering with US Club Soccer!!! Wow and gee willikers, Robin, what a splendid and novel idea. Now why didn’t “we” think of it sooner, and that finally someone sounds off against the EPL and vast armies of has-been “pros” whose bonafides are negligible or lacking! Wooah, what is this world coming to???

  3. Ooooops, woe is me, I forgot to ask just what is the NSCAA and US Soccer’s coaching programs have to say about La Liga providing us with a “coaching curriculum,” and what in sam heck is a “holistic club soccer experience?” Haven’t the two US coaching programs been involved in this before? Sounds like someone is trying to reinvent the coaching wheel here…. for a certain cost, of course!

  4. In 2003 Tahuichi did a clinic for NSCAA. When it was over 100s of coaches came to us and guess what they wanted? DVD!!! Head coach Ciro Medrano told the coaches we are not here to sell products. We are here to share what ever we can with all of you. If you want to see what we do. Come to Tahuichi. Bring your note pads and video cameras and film everything you want for free. Our doors are open for all of you. The US doesnt need more mercernaries to come suck the air out of our nation. We need 600,000 futsal courts in our inner cities and suburbs where kids can play 24/7/365 at no cost, no adult interference and a opportunity to compete everyday to see who will be king of the court. The US doesn’t need $400 cleats, coaching DVDs, coaching manuals, pretty uniforms, more soccer organizations, more tournaments or more smoke n mirrors. The kids need a playing/ sandlot/playground environment. US soccer needs radical change. We need new leadership. We need a new vision. We need a 21st century master plan. We need to create a NEW SPARTA!!!!!!! We need to create our WAY. The USONIAN WAY!!!!!!!!

  5. 1. What is their track record of producing talent?2. Do they play the kind of soccer we’re striving for?3. What’s in it for them?Hey Mike, Why dont “we” ask this of our current DA system and compare it to nonDA’s, right here, in USA?? What has been the impact? WHat has been the difference? The reason why we have so many Euro clubs coming here is because we dont sk those same questions of our own DA’s!! They see its a free for all!!

  6. As far as “what makes sense”?? No other plsaces make more sense to look at other than Brazil and Argentina. None other. They have produced the best and the most and will contin ue to do so. Whay does it have to be someone from Europe that we look to?? SPain?? Their best 2 teams are mostly not Spanish. Barcelona’s 3 best players are all South American !! How do these facts slip these SA journalists?

  7. Soc Mad… Brazil hasn’t really been the beautiful game place since around 1982 or so… most people wouldn’t hear of it 24 months ago, that mostly they are now thugs, playing ugly football… but Summer 2014 demonstrated this. the Flea was trained at Barca at La Masia, not in Argentina. You sort of overlooked the last decade, only recently over the past decades are Spaniards not dominating the Barca squad, but as old as Iniesta is, he still world class, Busquets is world class- one of the most underrated players in the world. Jordi Alba is world class. Where do the world’s best players go when they hit the big time? Spain!!!

  8. Mostly, this audience is familiar with EPL, so here you go: Santi Cazorla, Nacho Monreal, Arteta, Pedro, Cesc, Azpilicueta, Deulofeu, Alberto Moreno, Jesus Nava, David Silva, Juan Mata, David De Gea, Bojan, Michu… BUT do you recognize any of these? Xavi, Puyol, David Villa, Iniesta, Xabi Alonso, Pique, Busquets, Sergio Ramos, Iker Casillas, Koke, Jose Antonio Reyes, Alvaro Morata, Isco, Jordi Alba, Juanfran, Juan Bernat, Dani Carvajal, Vitolo, Paco Alcacer

  9. David, even playing ugly they are still exporting the most players of any other country and younger every year. You just further proved my point. More importantly, they still produce the best. I did include Argentina. So Messi didnt play any soccer 13 and down? I guess those years dont count huh? Most of his development doesnt count? The biggest problem in USA is that we think development starts when your a teenager or when you move top a bigger club. Dumb. Its like saying that all the NBA stars do all or most of their develoment for 1-2 years in college. Everybody knows NBA stars do most of what makes them better different in the hood. When we translate that to soccer, then we will produce the best. South America already understands that. That is why they will continue to produce the world’s best players while we jump from Euro country to Euro country scratchiung our heads as to why its not working. Barca? Have you forgotten Ronaldinho? Their go to players are never fromn SPain and they have the best school in SPain!!! LOL.

  10. David, none of those players you mentioned have ever been the best players or go to guys on their team. No doubt thgey are very good and USA would love to have them but if I am looking for a development model to follow as the very best there is no question I look to SOuth America to develop the very best. Your list will never compare to Messi, Ronaldinho, Suarez, Ronaldo, Zico, Pele, Maradona, Tevez, Di Maria, James, Rivaldo, Neymar, etc. Absoluetly never. The comparison is ludicrous. Brazil trashed SPain in Confeds right after they won WOrld Cup. Remeber that? Spain wins one world cup and gets trashed the next and we should follow them?? Ignore the winningst country of all ?? Brazil?? Lol

  11. USA top youth soccer minds have no intention in bringing us the best teachers or the best development models. If they did they would all come from SOuth America. They want to bring what will bring more $$$. What is more profitable. The latest fad.

  12. Hola Senores, we all seem to be on the same page, no matter our point of view. Yet, some seem NOT TO SEE THE TREES FOR THE FOREST, and her I refer to a US corporation with a bottom line, that of making some dinero (DON’T get me wrong, I’m for making a good honest living) and that is that ALIANZA “Sueno” group with some big name backers, e.g. Verizon, that actually conducts tryouts in some parts of the country more specifically at first look anyhow, to identify local talent – usually young Latino players – but with another goal and that is to find these kids and then supposedly “farm” them out to Liga MX teams. And then when we start crying over spilled milk and in our beers wheren we read about this young player, born in the US but playing for a Mexican or Central American team, but NOT for an ML:S team or much less for a college team, and decry the over the mere fact that we aren’t getting the locally trained and developed player duly noted and signed/recruited by local – read this US based – teams. Mind you, I am Mexican born, and yes cheer Mexico and Liga MX teams and am a strong supported of our US M/W National teams, but it rankles the beejasus outta me when I hear/read that these players are “getting away from us” meaning US based teams at whatever age bracket, collegiate or pro.Laslty as for joining forces with La Liga, OK, fine, but for sure they’re not doing it out of the kindness of their hearts, ’cause, pilgrims, they’re looking out for their bottom line also!

  13. We just cant just bring in the best talent in coaching into our broken system. The design of our federation model is broken. Until we solve our national federation issues with MLS, NASL, NWSL, NPSL, USL, NCAA, High School, Elite, AYSO, US Club, and 5 others i have missed as absurd fragmented structures that have no playing/coaching identity or philosophy without that how do we develop a real plan from youth to national level. Look at Belgium they went from 2001-2014 into a powerhouse and they didnt waste 1/10th what we waste.Its all about accountability, focus, strategy, vision, leadership, development.

  14. so true, so true… sure we all want pick-up games, and a culture change… but La Liga is the top league, and it is time for the brainwashing to end about other leagues… and true, one or two outlier comments here are comparting 60 years of players to a decade of players, it’s hard to know if one should be responding to those whose logic is so out there (probably not worth it). But Yes, I agree with you all, La Liga is the best league, Spain does have the most attractive style, they have been the best in the world over the last decade for club and country, and yes, their clubs have always been best in the world (National team finally got over provincial differences, at least socially, to pull together the best from the country over the past decade, and so we saw that translate into the best club players forming the best national teams). Wonderful, wonderful idea… smart to court La Liga.

  15. comparing, not comparting. The TV stations (fox, espn, abc, etc) need to get all the England biased commentators out too… hey, if you want a mix, that’s oK, but the england biased commentators dominate the American airwaves

  16. Agree on England commentators and agree on Spain having one of the best playing styles but if we want to look at the best development models it would without a doubt have to be from South America. Its not even close. If Spain developed the best players their best players on their best terams would all be SPanish or at least most of them. By best, I am talking about the go to guys. SPain can not say they develop the best players in the world. They had the best team in 2010. But still not the best players. I would think that USA would want to have the best most exiting players come out of their ranks. Thats what we do.

  17. Yes, I agree, Spain do have the best players. In regard to Real Madrid (team of the 20th century) it has been the World’s top team throughout the history of football, so can’t really talk about saying they are all best… the world’s team have the world’s best as a rule, so you’ve missed it with the simplistic logic that doesn’t really address reality… plus the way they develop, it isn’t the best, but their players are all over… Isco, Silva, Mataetc, etc, etc. And they do develop better than any England team… Barca now in stratosphere, and the better BaRCA (2010-2011 was a better team than the 2014-15 version) had 8 Spanish starters, so you are kind of talking vague generalities without really knowing the La Liga teams or the national team players..

  18. Reality? Reality is that Brazil and Argentina, as countries, both absolutely destroy Spain as pro player exporters and as Superstar producers. Thats reality for you. Barca is one club that has done a good job developing the most players for SPain. SO what you have are the 2 best teams in the world, Barca and Real Madrid, that both’s best players are hardly ever if ever SPanish. With the 2 combined right now the 3 best players are all SOuth American. Messi, Neymar and SUarez. In 2010 Messi was the best player on that team and Alvez top 3 the very least with Mascherano top 5 on that team. Thats your best argument?? A few years before that Ronaldhino was best on that team. SPain has the 2 best teams only because those 2 teams have the money to pay for the best players in the world who are always SOuth American. Spain naturalized a Brazilian for gods sake!! LOL. If USA wants to develop the best players possible they should look to South AMerica without a doubt.

  19. David, would Barca or Madrid be the best teams without Brazilians and Argentinians?? EVen close?? I can assure you this. We will never know. Those 2 will never risk to find that out. Case closed.

  20. No, picking all stars doesn’t mean one continent gets all the credit for being the top two teams in the stratosphere… you have weak logic, without spaniards they wouldn’t be best teams either. I do agree with you that Spain is best in style, in development, and they do have the best superior league… it’s very much either blindness, or ignorance to say the 3 best are south american, and again, you are correct that Spain is truly brilliant, and this is where the USA should turn, not England… it hasn’t done anything in international football for 50 years, and they were lucky then… we really do suffer from an ignorance of the European nation whose language is Castilian, we are very ignorant, and glad you pointed it out. I’m so glad that you have pointed out that UEFA’s top league is La Liga, and that no Brits even play on EPL teams… marketing job for sure.

  21. David, who exports more pros than Brazil or Argentina? Who develops the very best players in the world more often?? Whats weak about facts?? Sure SPain develops great role players. They devlop great team play. So the 3 best playuers on Barca right now arent South American?? Who is better on that team than Messi, Neymar and Suarez?? You better tell the owner cause he is paying the wrong guys the most money then !! LOL. So mSPain is great because England sucks? Thats ur point?? Why do so many people think we should have to follow a Euro model when South America undoubtably has produced the worlds greatest players?? Its like a country going to Argentina to learn basketball only because they won the World Championship one year and completely disregard the USA who cintinues to develop the best players!! Its DUMB.

  22. And whats better about SPain than oh lets say Germany right now?? They are the same in one thing. They look to South America for their best players along with Russia, England, Italy, etc. I’m not even SOuth American but those are facts. I want to see the best come here so we can develop the best. Not role players. Not team players. The best 1v1 players. The goal scorers. Thats what USA desperately needs. This team thing will not work here. You cant win without scoring goals. You can tie or not lose by much but you will only make yourself unwatchable. Barca is exiting only because of the SOuth Americans on it. Its a perfect blend. Without those 3 no one would watch them and they would not win as much as they do. Thats why they are paid so high. Wake up dude.

  23. This reminds me on the car industry in the US the last 40 years. we came up with excuses for 30 years on why we made great cars, standards where different etc.. excuses. We need a cold hard assessment of our quality. Period. I think we all can agree that the 2 top divisions in the top 10 leagues (and 3rd in England) and the top division in 10 other leagues in UEFA all have solid football style, development, coaching, culture etc.. Thats 500 clubs in UEFA and about 100-200 or so in South America all play better football for about 10 core reasons we all talk about. The question is of those 500-750 clubs in UEFA & South America how many could MLS teams beat week in and week out? much less how many NCAA top 25 teams or MLS/USL academy teams could beat the U19/21/23 teams of those top 500-750 clubs. if the numbers are low (we all know the truth) then we have a broken model on quality.

  24. Yes, thanks… you flatter me, but remember I am only answering this question from the perspective of this question: If we brought in outside influence, who would be the best? Clearly La Liga and Spain is the answer as you and the readers support hands down. However, that is not a substitute for our cultural change (pick up game football, fostering kids playing this type of game, IN ADDITION TO, but NOT IN PLACE OF structure club development training and experience. Both are required. Maybe my grandkids will have a chance when they are born… USA is simply not there yet, and still a generation away, ONLY IF WE CHANGE the culture, the longer we wait, the longer that championship won’t come to us

Leave a comment